The keyword phrase "September 11th Garfield" functions as a compound proper noun. In this context, "September 11th" acts as an adjectival modifier specifying a particular iteration of the proper noun "Garfield." The entire phrase serves as a unique identifier for a specific comic strip and the surrounding cultural event, rather than describing a general concept. Its grammatical classification as a proper noun is the main point because it names a distinct, singular entity: the notorious, coincidentally timed comic strip originally slated for publication on September 11, 2001.
The subject refers to a daily Garfield comic strip that was created months in advance but scheduled for release on the day of the 9/11 terrorist attacks. In the three-panel strip, Garfield is seen hiding, exclaims that it is "National Stupid Day," and warns Odie to run. A police officer then arrives to take Garfield away for an unspecified offense. Recognizing that the strip's contentfeaturing themes of alarm, hiding, and law enforcement interventioncould be grossly misinterpreted or perceived as insensitive in light of the day's tragic events, the syndicate (Creators Syndicate) issued a recall. Most American newspapers successfully replaced it with a substitute strip, but it ran in a few publications that did not receive the replacement notice in time, securing its place as an urban legend.
The practical application of understanding the term as a proper noun is that it allows for a precise discussion of a unique cultural artifact. The "September 11th Garfield" is not merely any Garfield comic from that date but a specific work whose intended meaning was irrevocably altered by external context. The event serves as a significant case study in media sensitivity, the role of syndication in print news, and how context can fundamentally redefine the interpretation of art. It is remembered not for its original joke, but as a peculiar and poignant coincidence in publishing history.
